Ders of this series already know about The mystery tself s nicely played out and although a little too sedate for my taste was a pleasant read I admit to being a bit n love with Inspector Ian Rutledge as damaged and driven and guilt ridden as he The Man Who Knew is Don t know how he can seem so kind caring soft hearted after what he endured Plus he s just so damned smart Yes yes I know I m going on about a fictional character but he seems real after reading 18 books with him as the main character Thiss typical Mount! in thatt nvolves many twists turns twisted love local dense policeman other usual village folk Definitely a police procedural but always with a difference Set as England recovers from the war with all the class differences still n place Doctor Who: Combat Magicks in rural England If you enjoy good British police procedural yarns the duo known as Charles Todd writes some doozies Theres so much back story t s best to start at the beginning though Otherwise you ll miss a lot of references that add depth to the story I used to read a lot mysteries than I do now when I ve gravitated towards thrillers and psychological suspense This book was a true mystery and a little too sedate for my taste It wasn t until two thirds of the way through
book that story actually became nteresting to me I have not readthis book that
Anything Else By Thiselse by this but this the 18th book n the series worked fine as a standalone I suspect however that the author s fans will like t than I didIn this book Inspector Ian Rutledge who has recently returned to Scotland Yard after serving There’s an Alien in Your Book in the First World Wars sent to Cornwall to nvestigate an attempted murder Rutledge works alone except for an maginary consciencecompanion named Hamish I gather that Hamish Girls on the Home Front is a standard presencen other books The Complete David Bowie in this series I foundt decidedly odd but not too Licence to be Bad: How Economics Corrupted Us intrusive I guess fans of the series liket I got no sense of who Rutledge Fundamentals of Nursing Care: Concepts, Connections Skills is or why he has been the focus of so many booksRight from the start I thought that there were too many suspects and too many red herrings which padded the book and led to a plodding story In this caset was literally plodding as Rutledge trudged from house to house nterviewing the same people over and over again Sometimes he Sigh I really really wanted to give this three stars but n all honesty I just can t One fine day four young women go boating on the river On the way home they encounter a man whose boat Seoul: A Window Into Korean Culture is sinking and of course they try to rescue him Or do they In the end the mans dead and the four friends are accused of murder Inspector Ian Rutledge Doctor Who: The Roundheads is calledn to nvestigate only to find a shocking lack of evidence and great resistance from everyone he talks to There are blustering fathers an evasive eyewitness old grudges unexplained night walkers and a mysterious young lady who cannot be found And bodiesThe plot sounds good but the execution was clumsy There were too many red
herrings that ultimately became nsignificant details and the final resolution which should have been a major part thanthat ultimately became Advanced Imagineering: Designing Innovation as Collective Creation insignificant details and the final resolution which should have been a major part than after thought was rushed and too easy given all thenitial misdirection In the beginning the writing was choppy and tentative though the pace and flow Around Town (LEGO Duplo Dk Readers. Level 1) improved as the book progressed Also the timing of this book was unclear Going by Ian s thinking and behaviort was difficult to tell at first Social Imaginaries of Space: Concepts and Cases ift came Developing Bus Rapid Transit: The Value of Brt in Urban Spaces in seuence with the rest of the series or was annsertion nto the timeline There were mentions of Ian s past loves Jean and Meredith which gave an ndication that there might be a happy future for him which Comparative Policing from a Legal Perspective is a good thing He didn t seem as troubled as he hasn past books although he did have a token thought of ending Connivance it all at the river which seemed to me to be stuckn as an The Rest of the Story impulse oh look here s a good place for a suicidal thought and Hamish made little appearance hereThis will be go on my keeper shelf but mostly because I have all the othersI received this uncorrected proofn a Goodreads giveaway NO SHRED OF EVIDENCE China-European Union Investment Relationships: Towards a New Leadership in Global Investment Governance? is book 18n the Inspector Ian Rutledge series I have only previously read the first book n this series but I had no problem getting nto this book There are some mentioning of events from previous books but I don t think one needs to read previous books to keep up with what s going on n NO SHRED OF EVIDENCEREAD THE REST OF THE REVIEW OVER AT FRESH FICTION. Ese four women sent to the nfamous Bodmin Gaol Then why hasn’t the killing stoppedWith no shred of evidence to clear the accused Rutledge must plunge deep Five Wakes and a Wedding into the darkest secrets of a wild beautiful and dangerous placef he s to find a killer who may or may not hold the key to their fa.
Charles Todd Ó 3 free readThe Ian Rutledge books make up
a superior series The mpact of World War I on English society s always apparent withinsuperior series The Curveball impact of World War I on English societys always apparent within An Elegy for Mathematics individual booksn the series The challenge of hunting murderers A Stranger on the Beach in a pre CSI worlds always Coming Home interesting The description of Rutledge s personal challenges deeply rootedn his wartime experience are freuently moving I look forward to each book eagerly Having said all that I have Strasberg at the Actors Studio: Tape-Recorded Sessions issues with No Shred of Evidence that won t lowerts 4 star rating but explain why t s no a 5 star book The description of these ssues must be preceded by a Spoiler Alert The crime that Rutledge A Witch's Guide To Faery Folk: How to Work With the Elemental World is sent to Cornwall tonvestigate sets up well Four young women who are boating go to the rescue of another boater a young man known to two of them at least whose boat appears to be sinking When their efforts prove to be a physical challenge a farmer dives The Homefront in Civil War Missouri into the river and swims to their assistance The rescued boaters n a coma however and the farmer accuses the young women of attempted murder Enter Rutledge So far so good The authors argues from the beginning that the farmer s word counts for than the collective testimony of the four young women apparently because the accused would
lie Celibate Passion if What happened to the assumption that the English system assumesnnocence and reuires the hard proof of guilt Whatever the nature of rural life Learning in the Cloud in Englandn the 1920s however Daniel Webster and Jacksonian Democracy insular Cornwall might have been compared to London the authorial assumption that eight hundred years of English law don t applyn rural Cornwall seems absurd To make the point even strongly the four young women are from the privileged class served The Gay Pretender in volunteer postsn the war and one Bloody Winter is the daughter of the largest landowner as well as the chief magistrate of the district If anything they would have gotten off without much of annuest Why does everyone assume that they are n line for hanging n the absence of eye witness testimony to the contrary Granted the assumption makes Rutledge s efforts fraught but Inventaire Sommaire Des Archives D�partementales Ant�rieures � 1790, Vol. 1: Mayenne (Classic Reprint) it seems an artificially contrived assumption There are two overlapping maybe maybe not crimes under consideration Ones a product of the farmer s charges and the recovered man s ultimate death The other revolves about a mysterious young woman whose presence n the town seems the focus of a dangerous person whose dentity like hers War Girls is not clear This second crime nexuss Hieroglyphen lesen. introduced effectively and developed well enough until suddenly rushed to a melodramatic conclusion Theres a scene when Rutledge realizes that he As Lágrimas Amargas de Petra Von Kant is under observation by a malevolent presence thats uite effective until Rutledge allows the stalker to move around the area without attempting to stalk him The stalker uses the boat that had sunk and been raised and apparently repaired unless Lesson Planning and Classroom Management it s the boat used by the women and rows back and forth across the river The boatsn t placed under observation Rutledge could have used the local constable a bit of a dunce to do that or staked The Stalin Front: A Novel of World War II it out himself And why doesn t anyone recognize the presence of the stalker as he moves around at night Given that hes physically fit unlike the other possible midnight walker would make The Nightmare Garden it easy to tell them apart The use of a costume once seems pretty thin stuff as a distraction And the many references to the Cornish beliefn spirits that go bump Look to the Mountain in the night by people from the area doesn t begin to explain why people don t notice a stranger at night The stalker could have been fleshed out better and Rutledge could have stalked him See Watchern the Shadows or Kill Claudio for examples of what a master writer can do with that kind of situation If I were Inspector Ian Rutledge I wouldn t leave my revolver n a trunk under my bed n London not when I spend my life tracking homicidal maniacs He s had to use his service revolver The Space Race: The Journey to the Moon and Beyond in at least eight or nine other cases 35 stars Having read this entire series thiss the one I have enjoyed the least But I could not give The Precarious: The Art and Poetry of Cecilia Vicuna / Vicuna, Cecilia. Esther Allen, tr. QUIPOem. Two books in one (Wesleyan Poetry) it a 2 star because Ians developing and there are portions of this which were a progression to the overall psychological changes as the years after the Great War turn one and then another and then another And now the differences from that just punctured psyche are beginning to evolve It was the plot and the placements this time that I thought much less The Color of Water inte. On the north coast of Cornwall an apparent act of mercys repaid by an arrest for murder Four young women have been accused of the crime A shocked father calls Mayan Strawberries in a favor at the Home Office Scotland Yards asked to review the case Inspector Ian Rutledge s not the first Inspector to reach. ,automatically lie f
Resting and probable both than the usual Ian Rutledge For nstance way too many red herrings and redundant testimonies which the reader knows are red herring or repeats for filler purposes from the get go Like an unconscious victim becoming audible suddenly and saying a name And you KNOW that Mistaken Mistress its NOT the name of the perpetrator just because of when he says Bunny: A Novel it This novel became tedious for 100 pagesn the middle exactly for those two reasons But what really was 2 star at core was the focal event of the 4 women trying to drown 1 man scenario as f that were a felony death sentence provable crime only from the word of another ONEman s differing and contrary to fact story of what he saw them do Not knowing 1920 British law I still believe that the entire thingordeal of those 4 women could have been reversed with the money and highly skilled family lawyers within a couple of weeks at least a month tops There was no evidence and no definitive witness And not even a motive worth considering for three of themThank God for Great Uncle s dear Elephant Gun s all I can add about this plotThree times during this read I wished Guido Brunetti would show up and rectify the misunderstanding Take all the women to dinner figure out which husband s brother s or probable boyfriend s PTSD or evil nature was The Great Smog of India impassioned and then have a good wine together while all the rest of them finish the evening by planning a vacation to Capri It would have been so much fun Ians way way too rigid uite beyond the emotive and mental war legacy to go with the flow of his job IMHO All this murdering beatings mayhem burning down of cottages etc sn t being done by 4 fashionable ladies with perfect hats to match Come on Guido would have know that without all the nterviews and could have slept late at the same time before his morning cappuccino hitLastly Ian better get a lucky and jolly girlfriend soon or he The Sex of the Angels, the Saints in their Heaven: A Breviary is going to become monkish And a better criminal case with some stylish Art Decon t would not hurt either Give him a weekend at Downton Abbey or Highclere Estate at least No vicarages or pig farms For the last several months I have been reading through the large spate of psychological thrillers being published all supposed to be the new Gone Girl or Girl on the train Some are good
SOME NOT BUT THEY HAVE ALLnot but they have all jumbled n my head one just blending Popular Hits in with the other and I grew tired of them It was so nice to return to straight out detective procedural or historical novels Need to catch up on some of my series of which thiss oneTwo years after the war ended Rutledge who s emotionally scarred from the Battle at Somme has returned to police work He carries some excess baggage with him the ghost or spirit f you will of a man from his battalion that he had to execute for disobeying a direct order His name s Hamish and he s Rutledge s constant companion I This outing four young well bred women are accused of killing drowning a young well of banker s sonThis period piece has such a great authentic atmosphere Slower paced detective work took time back The Creative Habit in the days before thenternet and social media they had to uestion witnesses sometimes several times travel which took longer and then uestion again Looking for a thread to pull and than following The Rest of the Story it with the hopeful end result of putting them together to form a complete pictureRutledges a likable character Hamish adds something a little special and a little different to this series Looking forward to the next case Eighteenth n the Inspector Ian Rutledge historical mystery series and revolving around an nspector suffering from PTSD This story takes place n Cornwall n the fall of 1920My TakeTodd jams us up Lords of Life: A History of the Kings of Thailand in a hard twist right from the start Four girls enjoying a last row on the river until they try to rescue a drowning man and e Thiss a very nicely written may I say genteel mystery set n England just after WWI This s the 1st I ve read n this
Series It Is Actually 18 In Thisit s actually 18 n this but t works fine as a stand alone The author s bio says Charles Todd Simon Spatz: From Holocaust to Halifax, A Story of Survival and Success is a mother son writing team I do not know how that works as far as writings concerned but they manage to portray a nice feeling of the manners and tone of that era The Scotland Yard detective Ian Rutledge A Life in Two Worlds is a good hero and he obviously has a back story that loyal rea. The village however Followingn the shoes of a dead man he The Hitler Kiss: A Memoir of the Czech Resistance is told the cases all but closed Even as The Doré Illustrated Balzac Droll Stories it takes an unexpected personal turn Rutledge will reuire all his skill to deal with thencensed families of the accused the grieving parents of the victim and local police eager to see th.